Tag: OSR
-
Actual Play Review: Mayfair Swordthrust (Plus: Errata)
tldr; It runs well and the players seemed to have a lot of fun with it. I’ve had some issues with it, and some errata (see below), but it’s been much easier to run than Deep Carbon Observatory. It strikes a nice balance between traditional fantasy and high weirdness. It’s hard to find authentic old…
-
Yet Another Mörk Borg review (Plus: An Index Card RPG comparison)
tldr; Great unhinged fun with the right group, but I can’t say how it would work long-term. I’ve played several sessions of Mörk Borg, each around 3 hours in length, at the time of this writing. The first two sessions were with a group of strangers online. The rest were with my regular gaming group,…
-
N1 Against the Cult of the Reptile God Review
I just finished running my PCs through the TSR-era Advanced Dungeons and Dragons module N1 Against the Cult of the Reptile God. It’s oft-cited as a favorite classic module and as a good 1st level/beginner module. Unfortunately, it’s highly overrated. System: The Green Hack (my variation of The Black Hack designed to improve compatibility with…
-
Black Hack Second Edition Review
tldr; Still a solid and simple system, but annoyances that could be deal breakers to some remain. Characters seem more powerful than in other old school games. I still think it’s best for one-shots or short-term play rather than campaigns. I prefer the original rules, but appreciate the tables and resources included with the new…
-
Winter’s Daughter actual play review
tldr; This is a good low-level adventure with excellent design and presentation. The enemies could be stronger and the traps could use more sign-posting, but this would make a good introduction to role playing for first time players. It works well as a one-shot in traditional European-style fantasy settings but easily serve as the start…